You do everything your coach tells you to do. Youre working out three or four times a week; youre going on long walks on your active recovery days; youre actually eating fruit and veggies every single day. And still theres that one part of your body that you flinch at when you glance in a mirror.
Its not surprising that many people want to change their problem areas when body image issues are so common throughout society. How could you not feel some kind of way about your body after scrolling through carefully-manipulated images on Instagram and checking out the bodies of people whose entire career is training? But if youve stumbled on the pervasive idea of spot fat reduction as a way to get rid of your belly fat, you might want to think again.
Of all the fat loss myths out there, spot fat reduction or just spot reduction persists as chief among them. Science says it just doesnt work like that, but athletes still hope it will. Figuring out exactly what the idea behind spot fat reduction is and learning why it is a myth can help you adjust your training to actually help get your body closer to where you want it to be.
Editors note: The content on BarBend is meant to be informative in nature, but it shouldnt take the place of advice and/or supervision from a medical professional. The opinions and articles on this site are not intended for use as diagnosis, prevention, and/or treatment of health problems. Speak with your physician if you have any concerns.
Spot fat reduction is a form of training that focuses on reducing subcutaneous fat in a particular part of your body. The logic is that by emphasizing a certain body part during your workout, youll encourage fat loss in that particular area.
For example, people may perform seemingly endless Russian twists and side planks if theyre not happy with the sides of their torso or hips. Or, an athlete might focus almost exclusively on bench presses and dumbbell flyes if theyre looking to reduce the size of their breasts.
There really isnt a way around it resistance training doesnt produce spot reduction. (1)(2) Although you cant lose body fat around your abdominals with crunches alone, supplementing cardio-based circuit training with core exercises might help reduce belly fat. (3) This makes sense, as core-specific exercises alone dont provide enough exercise intensity to create the calorie deficit that you need to lose weight. Adding cardio-based circuits to core training can, however, contribute to creating that deficit.
When someone has a goal of losing belly fat and follows an intense exercise program that includes core training, its tempting to conclude that this is, indeed, spot reduction. People lose body fat at different rates from different areas. If those areas happen to be the ones someone was hoping to lose fat from, then yes it might look like spot fat reduction at a glance. But research has shown that, for example, performing extra triceps exercises in the hopes of spot reducing fat from your upper arms doesnt work. (3)
Even if a training program is effective at reducing overall fat mass, emphasizing a particular part of your body wont make you lose more fat there. (4) In a study where participants trained their non-dominant leg three times a week for 12 weeks, overall fat mass went down but there wasnt a difference between their two legs. (4)
All that abdominal training certainly doesnt go to waste. Even though focusing solely on core workouts wont reduce body fat around your abs, it can significantly increase your abdominal muscle endurance. (5) Thats very important if youre interested in performing heavy compound lifts like squats, deadlifts, and overhead presses. Core strength and endurance are huge contributors to being able to lift heavy and often. Lifting heavy weights can, in turn, help you lose body fat overall if that is, indeed, one of your goals.
The same logic applies to training, say, your triceps or glutes. Spot reduction wont work, but you will still strengthen key areas of your body that can help you lift more effectively. Strong triceps, for example, are crucial for locking out heavy lifts like the bench press and overhead press. And you need powerful glutes for everything from squats and deadlifts to climbing all those stairs to get to your fifth-floor walk-up apartment.
Focusing on specific muscle groups in training can certainly encourage localized muscle growth. Thats because lifting weights requires your muscles to perform a certain amount of work that if youre eating enough food and giving them proper training stimuli leads your muscles to grow. But as much as you might want it to, localized muscle growth does not lead to localized fat loss. Heres why.
The idea behind spot reduction is to make particular muscles work extra hard. You might be searching for that burn you feel when youre doing endless triceps extensions, for example. But that burn is squarely located in your muscles its just your muscles working hard, not fat burning. Because technically, fat doesnt burn. It oxidizes, which means it gets broken down so you can use it for energy.
And while exercise can increase the oxidation of fatty acids for energy, those fatty acids come from your bloodstream. Along with your blood flow, these soon-to-be oxidized fatty acids flow toward the muscles that need them during your workout but they dont necessarily come from the area youre training. So exercise might contribute to general fat loss, but you cant really control where those oxidized fatty acids originate from.
Improving your overall circulation through full-body endurance exercise is a more effective way to oxidize fatty acids than working out one body part. (6) Fat loss doesnt happen in a discrete part of your body where youd like to reduce fat levels. It happens in your bloodstream when your body needs fuel.
Its not a coincidence that in cases where it looks like spot fat reduction is working, the athlete is performing both extensive core exercises and intensive full-body circuit training. (3) However, when athletes just perform core training (for example), theyre not providing enough training stimulus to drive general body fat loss through exercise, let alone specific fat loss in a particular location.
Only training one part of your body with isolation moves like crunches or Pallof presses wont really make a dent in how many calories you take in versus how many you use. Higher energy activities like circuit training or low-intensity, full-body activities like taking long walks will more effectively impact your caloric burn.
However, if youve decided to exercise to elicit a caloric deficit, make sure youre striking a steady balance. You need to eat enough to maintain your energy through tough workouts or long walks while also using more energy (AKA, calories) than you take in.
You need to be use more energy (AKA, calories) than you take in to burn fat. When this happens, your body needs to break down triglycerides a type of fat in your body made up of three fatty acids. These triglycerides get stored in your body when you dont use fat as energy right away. Its healthy and necessary for everyone to have triglycerides AKA, fat stored in their body. They helpmaintain cognitive function and baseline energy levels. (7) At the same time, its helpful to make sure your triglyceride levels arent so high as to interfere with your heart function and cardiovascular system. (8)
When you need to use them as energy, triglycerides break down into fatty acids. In turn, those fatty acids are transported throughout your body in your bloodstream. They break down even further and deliver energy to your muscles. (6)
To facilitate this process, you need protein, carbohydrates, and fat in your body. (6) In fact, research suggests that eating more dietary fat helps tell your body to oxidize more fat for energy. (9)
As for why you cant seem to lose that stubborn area of body fat, research suggests that effective long-term fat loss is all about consistency and finding a nutrition and exercise routine that is sustainable for you. (10)(11)(12)(13) Your hormones and other factors including genetics help determine the rate and location from which you lose fat faster. (14)(15)(16) Patience and consistency with your routine seem to be key for reducing body fat in those stubborn areas. (10)(11)(12)(13)
If one of your goals is to lose weight in a certain body part, spot reduction just wont do it for you. But that doesnt mean there arent other ways to get yourself closer to where you want to be.
Your old college roommate might swear by high-intensity interval training (HIIT) because those were the kinds of workouts that helped them lose weight. But if the idea of box jumps and burpees makes you never want to get off your couch, then rest assured you do not ever have to do box jumps or burpees.
Research has shown that the best way to stay consistent with an exercise routine is to enjoy what youre doing. (17)(18)(19) Instead of forcing yourself to perform workouts you hate, find a mode of movement that you love and try to stick to that. Maybe that means taking your dog out for longer walks, or maybe it means learning how to be a powerlifter.
When you like the way youre exercising, you start doing it because its fun rather than because you feel obligated to do so for a weight loss goal. When you genuinely like physical activity instead of forcing yourself through traditional exercises you hate youre better able to stick with it. (18)
Sticking with it helps you lose weight in a sustainable way. Its been found that consistency over time is the most effective way to sustainably change your body composition. (11)(12)(13) Experimenting to find a type of exercise you truly love will go a long way, no matter what your goals are.
Its tempting to only work out the specific area of your body that you want to change. But big full-body movementshave a better chance of changing your body. Since spot reduction isnt actually a thing, lifting heavy weights with compound exercises is a great bet for strengthening your entire body.
Forging a stronger and more muscular body lets you show off your muscles. The stronger you get, the more enjoyable your exercise program becomes and the easier itll be to stick to it. (19) And sticking to it helps you lose weight in the long-term. (11)(12)(13)
Exercises that involve your whole body require more energy than moves like planks or glute bridges. When you use more energy, you can more easily create the caloric deficit you might want if youre looking to lose weight.
But make sure youre striking a careful balance. If youre lifting heavy, you need to fuel your body so that you can safely maintain the energy you need to move big loads. You can lose body fat and gain muscle at the same time, but perhaps ironically you have to eat enough food to be able to do so.
Your nutrition habits tend to last over time if theyre sustainable for you emotionally and physically. Popular practices your gym buddies might talk about, like cutting weight or carb cycling, are not meant to last more than a few weeks at a time. Theyre supposed to produce temporary changes in your body and arent sustainable long-term.
On the other hand, being consistent with your nutrition over time is more effective than restricting what you eat. (11)(12)(13) Nutrition plans aimed at weight loss have to be sustainable to be effective in the long term. Studies have found that sustainable practices like intuitive eating can help people lose weight and not gain it back over long periods of time. (11)(12)(13)(20)(21)
Ultimately, fat loss can happen if your body is using more energy than its taking in. But keeping yourself in a state of perpetual caloric deficit can damage the messages your food-related hormones give you. (22) When youre chronically dieting, your body will send you chemical signals that youre starving even when you have plenty of food. (23) So when your goal is losing body fat, pay extra attention to your psychological and emotional relationship with food to keep yourself healthy overall.
If youre reading this because youre holding out hope for spot fat reduction, alas science says that spot reduction doesnt work. Exercising the muscles in the area you want to change just doesnt speed up fat loss there.
For reasons that you generally cant control (think: hormones and genetics), youll lose body fat from different areas and at different rates than other people. Sometimes, itll look like spot reduction if the way your body is losing fat happens to align with your goals. But that doesnt make spot reduction an actual thing that you can control.
Instead, try to find fat loss strategies that feel good for your body and mind. When your goal is fat loss, shift your focus to the bigger picture and the bigger picture is all about sustainability and enjoyment that allow you to be consistent.
Featured Image: LightField Studios / Shutterstock
Read more:
The Fat Loss Myth You Want to Be True: Spot Fat Reduction - BarBend
